In 2013, the auto‑insurance market was dominated by a handful of carriers that combined strong financial ratings, competitive pricing, and solid claim‑service reputations, making them the go‑to choices for drivers seeking reliable coverage.
More from this site
Keep reading the latest coverage
How the Rankings Were Determined
Ratings firms such as J.D. Power, AM Best, and Consumer Reports evaluate insurers on three core dimensions: price competitiveness, claim‑handling performance, and financial stability. The top ten list reflects carriers that scored above industry averages in all three categories, with particular weight given to customer satisfaction scores from the J.D. Power 2013 U.S. Auto Insurance Study.
Overview of the 2013 Leaders
Each of the ten companies below offers a distinct blend of premium levels, discount programs, and service quality. Understanding the trade‑offs helps you match an insurer to your driving habits, vehicle value, and budget.
Comparison Table
| Company | Average Premium (Full‑Coverage) | Claim Satisfaction (J.D. Power Score) | Financial Strength (AM Best) | Key Discount Focus |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| State Farm | $1,210 | 862 | A++ (Superior) | Safe driver, multi‑policy |
| Allstate | $1,250 | 845 | A+ (Excellent) | Driving‑behavior, vehicle‑safety |
| GEICO | $1,150 | 828 | A (Excellent) | Military, federal employee |
| Progressive | $1,180 | 815 | A (Excellent) | Usage‑based (Snapshot) |
| USAA | $1,090 | 889 | A++ (Superior) | Military & family |
| Farmers | $1,230 | 803 | A (Excellent) | Bundling, good‑student |
| Nationwide | $1,210 | 792 | A (Excellent) | Vanishing deductible |
| Liberty Mutual | $1,260 | 780 | A (Excellent) | Multi‑car, safe‑driver |
| American Family | $1,240 | 795 | A (Excellent) | Teen driver, loyalty |
| Travelers | $1,225 | 788 | A (Excellent) | Hybrid, bundling |
Key Trade‑offs to Consider
Price vs. Service. GEICO and Progressive typically post the lowest average premiums, but their claim‑satisfaction scores sit a few points below the industry leader USAA, which commands a higher premium. Drivers who prioritize cost above all else may accept a modest dip in claim handling.
Discount Breadth. Companies like State Farm and Allstate provide the widest array of discounts, from safe‑driver to vehicle‑safety incentives. If you qualify for several discounts, the net premium can drop below the advertised "average" rate, narrowing the gap with low‑price carriers.
Eligibility Restrictions. USAA remains the top performer in claim satisfaction, yet it serves only active‑duty military, veterans, and their families. Liberty Mutual and American Family have broader eligibility but lack the same financial‑strength rating as State Farm's A++.
Financial Strength Importance. A carrier's ability to pay out large claims hinges on its financial rating. State Farm, USAA, and Farmers hold the highest AM Best grades, offering extra peace of mind for high‑value vehicles or extensive coverage limits.
When to Choose a Specific Insurer
State Farm. Opt for State Farm if you value a local agent network, strong financial backing, and a proven track record in claim satisfaction. Their extensive discount program often offsets the slightly higher base premium.
GEICO. Ideal for price‑sensitive drivers who are comfortable with a largely digital experience and who can leverage niche discounts such as military or federal employee status.
USAA. The best fit for eligible military personnel who want the highest claim satisfaction and superior financial strength, even if the premium is modestly higher than the market average.
Progressive. Consider Progressive if you're interested in usage‑based pricing (Snapshot) that can reward low‑mileage driving patterns, despite a middling claim satisfaction score.
Allstate. Choose Allstate when you want a blend of decent pricing, a solid claims process, and access to the "Drivewise" telematics program for additional savings.
Final Thoughts on 2013 Selections
The 2013 top ten list shows that no single insurer dominates every metric. Drivers must weigh what matters most—whether it's the lowest premium, the highest claim‑handling score, or the strongest financial rating. By comparing the attributes in the table and matching them to personal priorities, you can select a policy that balances cost with confidence.