Why a 2018 Ranking Still Matters
Even though auto‑insurance rates change yearly, the 2018 rankings reveal which carriers consistently delivered strong financial stability, broad coverage options, and customer‑focused discounts. Understanding these fundamentals helps drivers evaluate current offers against proven industry leaders.
- Why a 2018 Ranking Still Matters
- Methodology Behind the Rankings
- Top 10 Auto Insurers in 2018
- Key Factors to Evaluate When Choosing an Insurer
- 1. Financial Strength
- 2. Coverage Breadth
- 3. Discount Portfolio
- Company Profiles: What Set Each Carrier Apart in 2018
- State Farm
- Geico
- Progressive
- Allstate
- USAA
- Liberty Mutual
- Farmers
- Nationwide
- Travelers
- American FamilyAmerican Family's "Pay‑as‑You‑Drive" program used mileage tracking to lower premiums for low‑use drivers, a niche that grew in popularity post‑2018.How to Use This Ranking for Your 2024 Purchase
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Do the 2018 rankings still reflect today's best insurers?
- Can I get the same discounts if I'm a high‑mileage driver?
- Is USAA available if I'm not military?
More from this site
Keep reading the latest coverage
Methodology Behind the Rankings
The list draws from three verifiable data sets:
- Financial strength ratings from A.M. Best, Moody's, and Standard & Poor's.
- Consumer satisfaction scores compiled by J.D. Power's 2018 U.S. Auto Insurance Study.
- Discount breadth and average premium data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) and publicly filed rate filings.
Each carrier received a weighted score (40% financial strength, 35% satisfaction, 25% discounts) and the top ten were selected.
Top 10 Auto Insurers in 2018
| Rank | Company | Financial Strength (A.M. Best) | J.D. Power Satisfaction (2022‑2023 avg.) | Key Discount Programs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | State Farm | A++ (Superior) | 842 | Multi‑vehicle, Safe driver, Good student, Military |
| 2 | Geico | A++ (Superior) | 835 | Multi‑car, Defensive driving, Federal employee, Military |
| 3 | Progressive | A+ (Excellent) | 828 | Snapshot usage‑based, Multi‑car, Safe driver, Student |
| 4 | Allstate | A+ (Excellent) | 822 | Multi‑car, Safe driver, Accident forgiveness, Military |
| 5 | USAA | A++ (Superior) | 870 | Member‑only (military), Multi‑car, Safe driver, Good student |
| 6 | Liberty Mutual | A (Excellent) | 815 | Multi‑car, Safe driver, New car, Pay‑per‑mile |
| 7 | Farmers | A (Excellent) | 808 | Multi‑car, Safe driver, Good student, Bundling |
| 8 | Nationwide | A (Excellent) | 804 | Multi‑car, Safe driver, Vanishing deductible, Military |
| 9 | Travelers | A (Excellent) | 800 | Multi‑car, Safe driver, Good student, Bundling |
| 10 | American Family | A (Excellent) | 795 | Multi‑car, Safe driver, Good student, Pay‑as‑you‑drive |
Key Factors to Evaluate When Choosing an Insurer
While the table offers a snapshot, drivers should weigh three core dimensions before purchasing a policy.
1. Financial Strength
A strong rating means the insurer can meet claim obligations even during large‑scale events (e.g., natural disasters). All ten carriers listed held at least an "A" rating, indicating high reliability.
2. Coverage Breadth
Standard policies include liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. Look for optional add‑ons such as rental‑car reimbursement, roadside assistance, and gap insurance. USAA and State Farm consistently rank highest for optional coverage variety.
3. Discount Portfolio
Discounts can shave 10‑30% off a base premium. Usage‑based programs (Geico's DriveEasy, Progressive's Snapshot) reward low‑mileage drivers, while bundling auto with home insurance often yields the deepest savings.
Company Profiles: What Set Each Carrier Apart in 2018
State Farm
With over 19,000 agents nationwide, State Farm combined personal service with a robust digital portal. Its "Drive Safe & Save" program leveraged telematics early, delivering up to 30% discount for qualified drivers.
Geico
Geico's direct‑to‑consumer model kept overhead low, translating into competitive rates. The 2018 "Geico Mobile" app introduced real‑time claim filing, a feature that later became industry standard.
Progressive
Progressive pioneered usage‑based pricing with Snapshot, gathering driving data via a plug‑in device. The company's "Name Your Price" tool let shoppers set a budget and receive matching coverage options.
Allstate
Allstate's "Drivewise" program offered cash‑back rewards for safe driving, while its "Deductible Savings" allowed drivers to lower premiums by opting for higher deductibles.
USAA
Exclusively serving military members and families, USAA earned the highest satisfaction score (870) in 2018, thanks to streamlined claims and personalized service.
Liberty Mutual
Liberty's "RightTrack" telematics program targeted high‑risk drivers, offering discounts after a 6‑month safe‑driving period.
Farmers
Farmers emphasized "SmartRide" – a usage‑based discount that could be combined with multi‑policy bundling for extra savings.
Nationwide
Nationwide introduced the "Vanishing Deductible" feature, which reduced the deductible by $100 each claim‑free year, up to $500.
Travelers
Travelers offered a "Multi‑Car Discount" that scaled with the number of vehicles insured, making it attractive for families.
American Family
American Family's "Pay‑as‑You‑Drive" program used mileage tracking to lower premiums for low‑use drivers, a niche that grew in popularity post‑2018.
How to Use This Ranking for Your 2024 Purchase
Even though rates evolve, the structural strengths identified in 2018 remain relevant. Follow these steps:
- Identify carriers with an "A" or higher rating.
- Check each company's current discount catalog; many 2018 programs have been expanded.
- Request a personalized quote that includes optional coverages you need.
- Compare the total out‑of‑pocket cost (premium + deductible) rather than premium alone.
- Read recent consumer reviews to gauge claim‑handling speed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do the 2018 rankings still reflect today's best insurers?
Yes, because financial strength and customer‑service culture change slowly. Most top‑10 carriers retained their "A"‑plus ratings through 2023.
Can I get the same discounts if I'm a high‑mileage driver?
Usage‑based programs like Geico's DriveEasy and Progressive's Snapshot reward low‑mileage drivers, but many insurers also offer safe‑driver discounts based on accident‑free history regardless of mileage.
Is USAA available if I'm not military?
No. USAA remains exclusive to active, retired, and eligible family members of the U.S. armed forces.