What Is a Hold Harmless Clause in Workers' Compensation?
A hold harmless clause (also called an indemnity or waiver of liability) is a contractual provision where one party agrees not to hold the other responsible for certain losses or claims. In the context of workers' compensation, it is often used in contracts between employers, subcontractors, and insurance carriers to allocate risk for on‑the‑job injuries.
More from this site
Keep reading the latest coverage
Why Employers Use Hold Harmless Provisions
Employers incorporate these clauses to protect themselves from lawsuits or additional costs that could arise if a worker is injured while performing duties for a subcontractor or third‑party vendor. By having the subcontractor agree to "hold harmless" the primary employer, the employer seeks to ensure that the subcontractor's insurance will cover the claim and that the employer will not be dragged into costly litigation.
Common Scenarios
- Construction projects where multiple contractors share a job site.
- Temporary staffing agencies placing workers at a host company.
- Outsourced maintenance or cleaning services.
Legal Limits of Hold Harmless Clauses
Workers' compensation laws are largely statutory, meaning states set mandatory coverage rules that cannot be waived by contract. Most jurisdictions prohibit a hold harmless clause from removing an employer's statutory duty to provide workers' comp benefits to its own employees. However, the clause can still be enforceable for third‑party claims, such as:
- Claims that the injury was caused by a subcontractor's negligence.
- Situations where the injured worker was not an employee of the primary employer.
If a clause attempts to waive the employer's core obligation to provide benefits to its own workers, courts typically deem it void.
How a Hold Harmless Agreement Is Structured
Below is a typical layout of a hold harmless provision used in a subcontractor agreement.
| Clause Element | Typical Language | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Indemnify | "Subcontractor shall indemnify and defend the Contractor against any claim arising from the Subcontractor's negligence." | Shifts liability for negligent acts. |
| Hold Harmless | "Subcontractor agrees to hold harmless the Contractor from any loss, cost, or expense related to workers' compensation claims." | Explicitly covers workers' comp exposure. |
| Insurance Requirement | "Subcontractor must maintain workers' compensation insurance meeting state minimums and provide certificates of coverage." | Ensures financial backing for claims. |
Practical Steps for Employers
1. Verify Insurance: Before signing, request a certificate of workers' compensation coverage from the subcontractor and confirm it is active.
2. Include Clear Language: Draft the hold harmless clause to specify the types of claims covered and any exclusions.
3. Review State Law: Some states (e.g., California, New York) have statutes limiting the enforceability of indemnity clauses in construction contracts.
4. Document the Agreement: Keep signed copies in the project file; they are essential if a dispute arises.
Practical Steps for Employees and Subcontractors
1. Understand Coverage: Confirm that your employer or the primary contractor's insurance will pay benefits if you are injured.
2. Know Your Rights: Even if a hold harmless clause exists, you retain the right to file a workers' compensation claim under state law.
3. Seek Legal Advice: If you believe a clause is being used to deny benefits you are entitled to, consult an attorney experienced in labor law.
Key Takeaways
- Hold harmless clauses shift risk for third‑party claims but cannot override statutory workers' compensation obligations.
- They are most effective when paired with verified insurance and precise contractual language.
- Both employers and workers should review the clause, confirm coverage, and understand state‑specific limitations.