What an A+ Rating Means in Life Insurance
An A+ rating in life insurance is the second-highest marks a carrier can receive from major independent rating agencies. It tells you the company has an extremely strong ability to pay claims, backed by a healthy balance sheet, conservative investing, and decades of reserve management. For buyers, it narrows the field to carriers built for long-term stability, which matters because a life policy can stretch across 20, 30, or even 40 years.
More from this site
Keep reading the latest coverage
Sofia Martínez has spent years covering how consumers evaluate financial products, and she notes that an A+ rating is not a guarantee against all risk — it is a signal about financial muscle, not customer service speed or pricing competitiveness.
Rating Agencies That Issue the A+ Grade
Four independent agencies dominate the U.S. life insurance rating landscape. Each uses its own scale, so an A+ from one does not map perfectly to an A+ from another.
- AM Best: A+ is the second-highest tier, right below A++. The scale runs from A++ (Superior) down through A (Excellent) and below.
- Fitch Ratings: Uses AAA as the top, with AA+ as the next tier down. Insurers sometimes reference their Fitch rating when speaking broadly about an A+ level of strength.
- Moody's Investors Service: Aaa is the highest, followed by Aa1, Aa2, and Aa3. An A+ equivalent sits inside the Aa range.
- Standard & Poor's: AAA is the top, AA+ is the next step, and AA sits just below that.
Why Financial Strength Matters for Policyholders
A life insurance contract is a long-term promise. You pay premiums over years, often decades, in exchange for a death benefit your family will claim far in the future. An A+ rated insurer has demonstrated the ability to absorb economic downturns, interest-rate swings, and surges in claims without failing to meet its obligations.
Key reasons this matters include:
- Claims-paying ability: Even in a severe recession, the carrier should have the liquidity and reserves to settle beneficiary claims.
- Reserve adequacy: Rating agencies scrutinize how much a company sets aside for future liabilities. A+ carriers typically hold conservative reserves.
- Longevity of the company: Many A+ carriers have been in operation for a century or more, surviving wars, market crashes, and industry shakeouts.
- Reinsurance and investment portfolio: Strong carriers diversify risk through reinsurance and maintain high-quality investment portfolios.
How to Compare A+ Rated Carriers
Shopping among A+ rated insurers requires looking past the rating alone. Two carriers with the same grade can differ sharply in pricing, product design, riders, and service experience.
| Factor | What to Compare | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Premiums for the same death benefit and term length | Rates vary widely between carriers, even among top-rated ones |
| Product range | Term, whole life, universal life, indexed options | Some A+ carriers specialize in term; others focus on permanent products |
| Riders and riders cost | Waiver of premium, accelerated death benefit, child riders | Add-ons can change the value proposition significantly |
| Complaint history | State insurance department records and BBB data | A strong rating does not prevent service complaints |
| Digital tools and support | App experience, agent network, customer service hours | Impact day-to-day convenience and claims filing |
Limitations of an A+ Rating
An A+ rating is a snapshot of financial strength, not a crystal ball. Rating agencies can and do downgrade carriers when conditions change. A company that held an A+ for years can slip if its investment portfolio suffers prolonged losses or if underwriting discipline loosens.
Other limitations include:
- Ratings do not reflect short-term profitability or stock price.
- They do not measure how quickly a company pays claims or how user-friendly its application process is.
- An A+ rating does not mean the lowest price — cheaper policies sometimes come from carriers with lower grades.
Steps to Verify and Use an A+ Rating
If an A+ rating is part of your decision process, take these steps before applying:
An A+ rating helps you filter the market, but the final choice should rest on price, product fit, and the experience you expect over the life of the policy.