Direct Answer
If a person named as a beneficiary in a life insurance policy is later convicted of murdering the insured, the payout is typically not given to that individual. Most policies contain a "murder‑for‑feit" clause that voids the benefit when the beneficiary is responsible for the insured's death, redirecting the proceeds to the estate or an alternate beneficiary.
More from this site
Keep reading the latest coverage
Understanding Murder‑For‑Feit Clauses
Life insurance contracts often include a specific provision—sometimes called a murder‑for‑feit or slayer rule—that states the insurer will not pay the death benefit to anyone who caused the insured's death. This clause is rooted in public policy: a person should not profit from a crime.
Key Elements of the Clause
- Applies only when the beneficiary is legally proven to have caused the death.
- Usually activates after the statutory waiting period (typically two years) for the policy's contestability.
- Directs the benefit to the estate or a contingent beneficiary named in the policy.
When Does the Clause Take Effect?
The timing depends on two factors: the policy's contestability period and the outcome of any criminal proceeding.
- Contestability period: Most policies allow the insurer to investigate claims within the first two years after the insured's death. If the murder is proven after this window, the insurer can still invoke the clause.
- Criminal conviction: The insurer generally requires a final conviction (or a civil judgment) before denying the claim.
Impact on the Insured's Estate
If the murder‑for‑feit clause is triggered, the death benefit becomes part of the insured's probate estate. From there, it is distributed according to the will or, if there is no will, according to state intestacy laws.
Estate Tax Considerations
When the benefit is added to the estate, it may increase the estate's taxable value, potentially subjecting it to federal estate tax if the total exceeds the exemption limit (currently $12.92 million in 2024).
Alternatives and Contingent Beneficiaries
Policyholders can protect their intended heirs by naming contingent beneficiaries—secondary recipients who inherit if the primary beneficiary is disqualified. This strategy ensures the money goes to a trusted party even if the primary beneficiary is later found guilty of murder.
State‑Specific Variations
While most U.S. states follow the slayer rule, the exact language and enforcement can vary. Below is a quick comparison of how three states handle the issue.
| State | Statutory Basis | Key Detail |
|---|---|---|
| California | Cal. Civ. Code § 340.5 | Benefit passes to estate; no payment to slayer. |
| New York | NY Insurance Law § 3420 | Allows insurer to deny claim and direct proceeds to contingent beneficiary. |
| Texas | Tex. Ins. Code § 541.006 | Requires proof of homicide; proceeds go to estate. |
Practical Steps for Policyholders
To avoid unintended loss of benefits, consider these actions:
- Review your policy's murder‑for‑feit clause and understand its language.
- Designate contingent beneficiaries who would receive the benefit if the primary is disqualified.
- Consult an estate‑planning attorney to align life insurance with your overall will or trust.
- Keep beneficiary designations up‑to‑date after major life events (marriage, divorce, birth).
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the insurer pay the benefit before a conviction? Generally no; insurers wait for a final legal determination to avoid premature payouts.
What if the murder is never prosecuted? Without a conviction, the insurer may still deny the claim if there is clear evidence of wrongdoing, but the burden of proof is higher.
Does the slayer rule apply to accidental deaths? No; the rule only applies when the beneficiary is proven to have caused the death intentionally.