What Is a Workers' Compensation Election Against?
In a handful of U.S. states, employees have the right to elect against receiving workers' compensation benefits for a specific injury or illness. This election, sometimes called a "workers' compensation election against" or "opt‑out," allows an employee to pursue a lawsuit for damages against the employer or to seek compensation through other avenues, such as health insurance or a personal injury claim, instead of relying on the state's workers' comp system.
More from this site
Keep reading the latest coverage
Legal Foundations and State Variations
The right to elect against is not universal. It exists in states like New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, where the workers' compensation statutes explicitly provide employees the option to decline the system's benefits. In these jurisdictions, the election is typically governed by a statutory deadline—often within 30 to 90 days after the injury is discovered—and requires written notice to the employer and the state workers' comp board.
Why Would an Employee Choose to Elect Against?
Employees may opt out for several reasons:
- Higher Potential Damages: Workers' compensation often caps non‑economic damages. A lawsuit can recover punitive damages, loss of future earnings, or other compensatory amounts not covered by the state system.
- Specific Legal Claims: If the injury results from negligence, discrimination, or a violation of federal law, a personal injury suit may provide a broader remedy.
- Insurance Coverage: Some workers have supplemental insurance plans that offer better benefits than the state's standard payout.
Process for Making the Election
Employees must follow a strict procedural framework:
| Step | Description |
|---|---|
| 1. Notice | Submit a written election notice to the employer and the state workers' comp board within the statutory time frame. |
| 2. Confirmation | Receive written confirmation from the board that the election has been accepted. |
| 3. Legal Representation | Hire an attorney experienced in workers' compensation and personal injury law to assess the merits of a lawsuit. |
| 4. Litigation | File a claim or lawsuit, gathering evidence of injury, negligence, and damages. |
Risks and Considerations
Choosing to elect against is not without risk. If the employee's claim fails, they may lose the benefits they would have received from the workers' comp system, which includes medical coverage and wage replacement. Additionally, the employer may pursue counter‑claims or seek to recover costs associated with the lawsuit. Employees should weigh potential benefits against the possibility of a lower or denied outcome.
Practical Tips for Employees
• Act Quickly: The deadline for election is tight. Contact your employer's HR department and the state board immediately after an injury.
• Document Everything: Keep records of medical reports, witness statements, and any communication with the employer.
• Consult a Specialist: A lawyer who knows the local workers' compensation law can advise on the likelihood of success and the best strategy.
• Understand the Cap: Workers' comp often limits certain damages. Knowing these limits helps evaluate whether a lawsuit could offer a significant advantage.